Is Tin Cheaper Than Asphalt Roofing? Keeping Durability and Cost in Check In general, asphalt shingles are less expensive initially, which appeals to homeowners looking for cost-effective solutions. However, despite being more costly initially, tin roofing has remarkable endurance and can eventually endure more severe conditions. Because of its durability, tin is a wise investment for people who intend to stay in their houses longer and who wish to reduce the cost of future repairs and replacements. Therefore, even if asphalt is initially less expensive, tin's durability may add more value over the roof's lifetime, offsetting the initial cost.